Conscious Chief Executives E-zine - Issue #04

How Can We Improve Attendances at Board Meetings?

Steven Bowman
This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Have you ever had (or heard of) the situation where one or more Board members were either consistently late, or were not turning up on a regular basis (with or without pre-warning). This is one of the most consistent comments we receive from CEOs and Board members when we conduct nonprofit governance audits and reviews.

I would first of all like to make the distinction here between Board member involvement versus Board member attendance. Board member involvement is where the Board member, even if they are unable to attend a particular meeting, has read the papers, discussed issues with the CEO and Board Chairman, and has made a strategic contribution to the meetings agenda. Board member attendance should include all the previous contributions, plus they attend the meeting as well.

If your Board member is not reading the papers, not discussing issues with the nonprofit CEO and Board Chairman, and not making a strategic contribution, then it really is an issue of whether they should be a Board member at all, not one of attendance. The true question to ask yourself is: “Are they not attending because they are not functioning as a Director should, or are they not attending because the meetings are not making a true difference strategically.”

If they are not functioning as a Director should, then they need performance management or invited to leave the Board. If the meetings are not making a true strategic difference, then the following strategies might make a difference.

The reasons most Board members chose not to attend meetings are that they view the meetings as inefficient, too operational, same/same, or sometimes just too boring. One director said to us recently as part of a Board review we were conducting, "I am not sure why I should attend all Board meetings, they are just discussing the same old things, and I have to travel two hours to get there, so I am not going to make a huge effort for meetings that are essentially all the same". Are your meetings like this?

If you find people giving excuses or justifications for not attending meetings, realise these are just that: excuses and justifications. They are actually choosing not to attend. If they say.."I am too busy today".. it’s just a choice they have made. If they say.."I got caught up, something came up"… just a choice. If they say "It’s really busy at work at the moment"…I think you are seeing the pattern here.

What would it look like if you could guarantee your board members that they would go away from every Board meeting with new skills, greater strategic insights, and business acumen that they could translate into their own business and life? What if they were making strategic decisions that affected the future of the organization and the sector it represents? Would that make a difference in their attendance? If not, then they may wish to reconsider their membership of the board.

Some strategies that make a difference in nonprofit Board attendance:

• Restructure the Board agenda so it reflects the key elements of the strategic plan. This keeps the Board focused on those key areas that the Board has responsibility for, and assists in strategic decision making.

• Develop a staff report section at every second or third Board meeting, where a staff member verbally reports to the Board on the strategic issues facing their area of responsibility, and is questioned by Board members regarding these strategic issues. Ensure these reports are directly linked to the strategic plan and vision/mission, and focus on issues not activity.

• Recast all reports from CEO, staff and committees so they directly relate back to the strategic plan, identify the key strategic issues and discussion points, and make recommendations or provide ranges of options.

• Include "Changes to Strategic Environment" as a standard section in Board agenda as the last discussion segment of the Board meeting. This is an opportunity to discuss any major changes, shifts or trends we need to be aware of that might impact on our strategic assumptions.

• Develop guest speaker sessions to support the Board. This might include presentations from other CEO’s of like organizations, funding bodies, academics etc.

• Consider developing part of the Board meeting as an in-camera session (without staff) to discuss matters of Board performance, individual Director issues and any other issue where it would not be desirable to have a staff member present (even if they are also a Board member).

• Ensure your Chair has the required Chairing skills. Consider implementing a regular review by the Board (every 6 months) of the Chairs skills and their effect as Chairman. Realise that, if the Board put the Chairman in that position, they can (and should) also remove them from that position if the Chairing is not producing optimum results. (This is not a popularity contest!)  Click here for some articles on Chairing>>>>

• Conduct an annual review of the Board, where you evaluate Board functions and what can be improved. Click here for some articles on Board reviews>>>> 

• Provide external accountability through the annual report, AGM and stakeholder engagement strategies, including meeting attendance and how the skills of the Board members are matched to the strategic needs of the organization.  Click here fr an annual report checklist and other governance tools>>>>

• Develop a formal mentor system for new Board members to facilitate understanding of amongst other things, what constitutes Board and management matters, and why, and the decision making processes utilised to make those determinations. Match mentors with new Board members based on skill in mentoring.

• Conduct an annual forecasting/strategic review session with Board and staff that employs technologies such as strategic foresight, scenario building, backcasting, causal layered analysis etc to test out assumptions. Consider including a skilled futurist.

• Don’t let non-attendance go on!!

What strategies or techniques have you found useful to increase Board member attendance and involvement? Let me know, and I will pass these on in the next issue. ( This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it )

If none of these work, and a Director’s attendance and involvement is still unacceptably low, then it is time for the Succession Planning Committee (sometimes called the Governance, Evaluation or Remuneration Committee) and the Chairman to fulfill one of their roles- performance management of the Directors. This will be the topic of the next e-zine- “How do I get rid of a Director?” This is one of the most contentious issues that face Boards today, and one that we are often asked to advise on. I welcome your views and insights.

What's New?

Click here for more information and to order >>>> "Strategic Risk Management: Risk as Strategic Advantage for Nonprofit Leaders"

This Chief Executive Quick Guide has been formulated to provide leading edge perspectives and techniques on topics particularly relevant to chief executives of nonprofit organizations around the world. This Quick Guide has been tested in the real world of nonprofit Board rooms and senior leadership teams, and is designed to provide points of view on key areas of chief executive responsibilities in terms of risk management. Only US$45.00, this Quick Guide is available as a downloadable e-book immediately.

Click here for more information and to order >>>> 
 

"The Conscious Chief Executive-Leading Your Nonprofit Organization to Success from Awareness"

This book is based on the awareness that all nonprofit organizations have unlimited potential and possibility to become successful and thriving if they are led by conscious leaders. This book shows what it would take for chief executives to become conscious leaders and to embody and be the greatness of who they truly are. It provides chief executives of nonprofit organizations a practical conscious leadership "toolbox" of strategies. Only US$35.00, this is available as a downloadable e-book immediately.

Click here for more information and to order >>>> 
 

"Advanced Strategic Planning-Strategic Planning that works for nonprofit Boards and Leaders"

What would it take for your strategic plan to be truly strategic? Do you want to know how to embed the strategic plan into all facets of your organization and get amazing buy-in from Board, staff and stakeholders? Do you want a process that is quick, focused and provides step-by-step guidelines that result in a strategic plan that is accountable and measurable? Only US$45.00, this Quick Guide is available as a downloadable e-book immediately.

Click here for more information and to order >>>>

Strategic Plan Facilitation

Contact Steven Bowman for an invitation to work with us to create your strategic plan that is truly strategic with embedded project action plans: in 1 day, involving key stakeholders, with full accountability to the Board, staff and stakeholders., and a strategic plan that creates change at the Board, staff and community level

Who else would find this useful? Forward this e-zine

Know somebody who'd like to read this?

We really hope that you've enjoyed reading this e-zine. If you think your colleagues might be interested in taking a look, please feel free to forward it to them or give them this link: 

http://www.conscious-governance.com/Nonprofit-Executive-Articles/e-Zine/join-the-conscious-chief-executives-free-e-zine.html

Haven't subscribed yet?

If you're reading this on the recommendation of a friend and would like to receive all the future editions, you can subscribe for free by clicking on t he following link.

Subscribe to FREE e-zine

Previous Issues Topics

Issue #001 -- When Board members step over the line

Issue #002 -- How can the Chair and the CEO work together productively?

Issue #003 -- What are the Powers of Members vs Nonprofit Boards?

Click here for links to back issues

Next Issue Topic

Next issue will focus on nonprofit Board remuneration (should we, shouldn't we, and why), a very emotive topic that has arisen more frequently in the past few months. (Mind you, I might change the topic if something even more topical comes in. Let me know what you would like to see!)

Please send us any of your feedback, or any questions that you might like to see in the e-zine. All communications are confidential.
Happy reading
Steven Bowman

Contact Us

Contact us if you would like more information on any of the following:

Board and Governance audit and review Our Strategic Governance review is a comprehensive independent review of Board processes, including Board strategic processes, Board structure, Board and stakeholder communication, Board compliance responsibilities and strategic operational issues that directly affect the governance of your organization.

Strategic Planning facilitation Our Strategic Planning process encapsulates the most robust, time-efficient planning techniques to provide a focused, vision driven strategic plan, with value added components that embed the strategic plan into the Governance and operational framework of the organization. Powerful success measures, a unique ethics filter, strategic reporting frameworks and strategic thinking processes are end results of our Strategic Planning process.

Strategic Plan annual review facilitation Is your strategic plan on track? Our strategic plan review facilitation provides a focused forum for reviewing your existing strategic plan, with four key questions explored?1. What has worked with our strategic plan 2. What has not worked with our strategic plan 3. What has changed in our environment 4. What do we need to add or take out of our strategic plan

Telephone (61)3 95099529
Mobile 0438 325 782
Email us steven @ conscious-governance.com
Conscious Governance website www.conscious-governance.com
Physical address: 17 Gordon Grove, Malvern Australia 3144